PG-13, 1 hr. 57 min. Directed by: Stuart Baird. Release Date: December 13, 2002. DVD Release Date: May 20, 2003.
My sixth grade year, circa 1989, my parents moved me from the LA ‘burbs to San Jose. I found myself in public school for the first time. It was a hard year, full of me being forced to changes that I didn’t particularly want. But, it was at Monroe Middle School in San Jose that I met the guy who was probably my last best friend. Or at least, the last time I could name my “best” friend without having to quantify the concept. In the decade we were in touch, Justin shaped my life in a lot of ways, although I suspect he never realized it, because I didn’t until I thought about it while writing this entry of The Great Movie Project. Every day, Justin’s mom would pick us up from school and I’d hang out at his house until around 6. We’d watch movies or TV, sometimes do homework, and drink a lot of soda. He is probably single-handedly responsible for my ridiculous Coke(a-Cola) habit that survives to this day. He helped shape my love of movies in general and of science fiction in specific. He also introduced me to Star Trek: The Next Generation, which was probably in its third or fourth season at the time. I learned to love Trek in a way he never did, which was completely and intellectually. I love the political modeling used to make the show and its fifty bazillion (and increasingly sucky) spin-offs a little better than they might otherwise have been. I love that the show handles subjects that no one else will touch, even if the presentation is a bit silly and removed. Star Trek made television history for showing us the first interracial kiss, episodes have been written that criticized racism, homophobia, corruption, have promoted personal honor and responsibility, and dealt with more social issues in a single season than most shows handle in a lifetime.
I have immense respect for the various casts and crews of Star Trek, but, I’m going to be honest, I get into a bit of nerd rage about this movie. I was always more of a Trekker than a Trekkie; I didn’t do conferences or ears, but at one time I thought Marina Sirtis was one of the most beautiful women alive, and I still want to hang out with Patrick Stewart, but in my heart, I believe that this movie deserved better than it got. More than any other TNG movie, this felt like a really long episode. In fact, it felt a bit like the Borg two-parter that happened in the middle of the show’s run. Once again, the Enterprise is the ONLY ship in the quadrant… which happens to hold the majority of the neutral zone that serves as border between the Federation and its oldest enemy. Even the Canadian-American border has stops now, so I’m finding that part hard to believe. We have a bad guy that is supposed to resemble a young Patrick Stewart, although he looks nothing like the pictures we’ve seen of Jean-Luc Picard in his Academy days.
And let’s talk about the bad guy, whose wardrobe appears to have been co-designed by a ringwraith and Lady Gaga while high. Seriously? I’ll probably never forgive Brent Spiner for the ending of this, which shocked me so much at the time that I felt the blood drain from my face. If you haven’t experienced that cold, sick feeling, it’s not fun. Also. Please give up on Stellar Cartography and it’s “uplink to Starfleet Cartography.” Yes, we get it. Someone over there developed a cool star chart and it’s a reference to Google Maps.
But, at its core, Nemesis is a total Trek experience. Our favorite members of Starfleet go head to head with one of their biggest, baddest adversaries. Ever. There’s political intrigue, a hell of a lot of shenanigans, and a pretty amazing fire fight with the Enterprise and two Romulan ships on one side, and a supership on the other. The special effects are exactly what we’ve come to expect from Gene Roddenberry’s brain child.
Unlike some of its predecessors, there’s plenty of action, although not all of it is on a ship-to-ship level. The premise is very strong… although like much of the details, it also violates existing Trek cannon. I can get over that. I don’t go see one of these movies because it exactly mirrors every episode, every published novel and fanfic (I swear I don’t read those. Really.) and every other movie made to date. I like the idea of story cohesion, but if that story is interesting enough, it can deviate from the existing plot lines. This could have been a great movie if it had not only generated that amount of interest, but managed to successfully changed the path of Trek history. As it is, Nemesis is a better than mediocre movie. There are a lot worse ways to spend two hours, like Star Trek V, which is so terrible I can’t even remember what its subtitle is.